Research Article |
Corresponding author: Tiara S. Cabral ( ttiara@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Bryn Dentinger
© 2019 Tiara S. Cabral, Bianca DB. Silva, María P. Martín, Charles R. Clement, Kentaro Hosaka, Iuri G. Baseia.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Cabral TS, Silva BDB, Martín MP, Clement CR, Hosaka K, Baseia IG (2019) Behind the veil – exploring the diversity in Phallus indusiatus s.l. (Phallomycetidae, Basidiomycota). MycoKeys 58: 103-127. https://doi.org/10.3897/mycokeys.58.35324
|
Studies have demonstrated that many cosmopolitan species actually consist of divergent clades that present high levels of morphological stasis throughout their evolutionary histories. Phallus indusiatus s.l. has been described as a circum-tropical species. However, this distribution may actually reflect the lack of taxonomic resolution due to the small number of diagnostic morphological characters, which leads to the identification of new records as populations of P. indusiatus. Here, we examine the diversity of P. indusiatus-like species in Brazilian Amazonia. We show a clear congruence between detailed morphological data and ITS, nuc-LSU and atp6 based phylogenetic analyses and three new species are described within the Brazilian indusiate clade. These results highlight the importance of more detailed investigation, with the inclusion of molecular information, in Neotropical fungi.
Amazonia, atp6, ITS, Neotropics, nuc-LSU, Phallales
The worldwide distribution of fungal species hypotheses has been questioned by modern molecular analyses. Studies have demonstrated that many cosmopolitan species actually consist of divergent clades that present high levels of morphological stasis throughout their evolutionary histories (
As in phalloid fungi in general, few morphological characters are available to delimit species in Phallus. In addition, most of the widely used diagnostic characters – such as colour and sizes – show high plasticity, another factor that may lead to misidentifications and mask the real diversity within the genus (
Due to lack of resolution when using morphological characters to identify Phallus species, we believe that several specimens that have been identified as P. indusiatus might actually consist of independently evolving entities. In fact, some new species with minimal, yet noticeable morphological differences from P. indusiatus, have been proposed. For instance, P. serrata H.L. Li, L. Ye, P.E. Mortimer, J.C. Xu & K.D. Hyde, described for China, differs by the meshes of the indusium with serrate edges (
Phallus indusiatus was described by Étienne Pierre Ventenat in 1798, based on a specimen from Suriname. In 1809, Desvaux created a new genus, Dictyophora Desv., mainly characterised by the presence of an indusium, a skirt-like structure that expands from the receptacle towards the ground. Ventenat’s species was transferred to Dictyophora and named D. indusiata (Vent.) Desv.
In this study, we examined the diversity of P. indusiatus-like species in Brazilian Amazonia. We show a clear congruence between detailed morphological data and DNA-based phylogenetic analyses and three new species are described within the Brazilian indusiate clade. These results highlight the importance of more detailed investigation, with the inclusion of molecular information, in Neotropical fungi.
Specimens of Phallus sp. with white indusium were collected during the rainy seasons of 2013 to 2015 in various areas of the Amazon Rainforest domain (Figure
DNA extraction followed
We submitted each sequence to a BLAST search to identify the closest relatives and to check for possible contamination. The closest sequences resulting from the BLAST search and sequences with genus names of Phallus or Dictyophora were retrieved from GenBank and added to the dataset. All sequences were aligned and manually edited with Geneious R6.1 (Biomatters Ltd.). Two analyses were run, one for the ITS dataset (ITS) and the other with ITS, nuc-LSU and atp6 concatenated matrix (CONC). The ITS final aligned matrix contained 618 positions, while the concatenated matrix contained 1896 positions (571 for ITS, 794 for nuc-LSU and 529 for atp6). These two matrices were analysed separately. Based on a previous phylogeny (
A total of 19 recently collected specimens of Phallus spp. with white indusium were studied, 15 of which were collected in Brazilian Amazonia, while four other specimens were collected from the Brazilian Atlantic Rainforest (SP and UFRN-Fungos herbaria) (Figure
We obtained 95 sequences, amongst which 54 were ITS, 19 were nuc-LSU and 22 were atp6 (Suppl. material
Phylogenetic tree obtained by Bayesian analysis with ITS. Brazilian clades corresponding to the new species and P. indusiatus are indicated (the holotype of each species is in bold). Posterior probabilities and bootstrap values are on the nodes (pp/bs), values of pp < 0.95 and bs < 90 are not shown. The black dots indicate specimens under Phallus indusiatus deposited in GenBank and downloaded for this study.
Phylogenetic tree obtained by Bayesian analysis with concatenated data (ITS, nuc-LSU and atp6). Brazilian clades corresponding to the new species and P. indusiatus are indicated (the holotype of each species is in bold). Posterior probabilities and bootstrap values are on the nodes (pp/bs), values of pp < 0.95 and bs < 90 are not shown (except for P. denigricans clade).
This species is characterised by the campanulate receptacle slightly constricted at the base, pale yellow, reticulated, with a prominent apical pore, epigeous development of basidiome, volva varying from white to dark brown and spores up to 4.6 × 2.5 µm.
BRAZIL. Amazonas: São Gabriel da Cachoeira, Itacoatiara Mirim Community (0.304167S, 66.8403W), 1 April 2013, Komura DL (INPA-Fungos 272383). GenBank accessions: MG678486 (ITS), MG678455 (nuc-LSU), MG678541 (atp6).
Immature basidiomes not observed. Fresh expanded basidiome 98 mm high. Receptacle [25] 26 × 19 [25] mm, campanulate, but slightly constricted at the base, with a prominent apical pore, deeply reticulated surface. Pseudostipe [81] 54 × 10 [22] mm, cylindrical, spongy, white (N00A00M00); pseudoparenchymatous, composed of globose to elongate-ovoid cells, [20.5] 18.5–65.5 [60.8] × [17.5] 19–52.5 [51.2] µm, hyaline. Indusium poorly developed, extending to 2/3 of pseudostipe, white (N00A00M00), 53 mm in length, attached to the apex of the pseudostipe, polygonal to irregular meshes up to 13 × 8 mm. Volva epigeous, white (N00A00M00) in some specimens to dark brown (N60A60M50) in others, with smooth surface or sometimes with small hyphae projections on surface; formed by filamentous hyphae, septate, branched, hyaline, clamp connections present, [2.5] 1.8–5 [3.5] μm diameter, with inflated ends up to 15.5 μm diameter. Rhizomorphs composed of at least two types of hyphae: filamentous thin-walled hyphae, with clamp connections; and thicker hyphae (7–16 µm) that seem to communicate with each other by pores on the inflated tips. Crystals in globose cells were found distributed amongst the hyphae of volva and rhizomorphs of some of the white volva species, measuring 8.2–11.5 × 6.8–10.6 μm. Gleba olive brown (N99A50M10), mucilaginous. Basidiospores elongated, smooth, 3.6–4.6 × 2.2–2.5 µm, hyaline in 5% KOH.
Phallus denigricans UFRN-Fungos 2805, holotype. A Basidiome B blackish and smooth volva in detail C white volva with projections D receptacle with a prominent pore E spores F pseudoparenchymatous hyphae of pseudostipe G hyphae from rhizomorphs H hyphae from volva. Scale bars: 20 mm (A–D), 20 µm (E), 40 µm (F–H).
On soil, in a fragment of upland old-growth forest. So far restricted to the Brazilian Atlantic and Amazon forests, found in the municipalities of Barcelos, Parintins, São Gabriel da Cachoeira and Maraã (State of Amazonas, Brazil); and Natal (State of Rio Grande do Norte).
with reference to the volva becoming blackish.
Brazil. Amazonas: Maraã, Reserva de Desenvolvimento Sustentável do Amanã, Ubim Community (2.50500S, 64.66039W), 15 February 2014, Cabral TS (UFRN-Fungos 2805). Barcelos, Bacabal Community (0.49004S, 62.93089W), 7 April 2015, Cabral TS (INPA-Fungos 277791). Parintins, Açaí Community (2.62665S, 56.54041W), 5 March 2015, Cabral TS (INPA-Fungos 272375); 6 March 2015 (INPA-Fungos 272378); Barcelos, Bacabal Community (0.49004S, 62.93089W), 7 April 2015, Cabral TS (INPA-Fungos 272381, INPA-Fungos 272382). Rio Grande do Norte: Natal (6.305093S, 35.361112W), 10 September 2005, Barbosa MMB (UFRN-Fungos 417).
Phallus flavidus Kreisel & Hauskn. could be comparable with P. denigricans by the conical receptacle and the indusium size; however, P. flavidus has smaller spores (up to 3.6 × 1.8 µm), the surface of the volva is light grey with an orange flush and the indusium is cream to yellow (
It is not rare to find Phallus specimens with a blackish volva; recently, a new species was described, P. fuscoechinovolvatus (
In both the Bayesian and Maximum Parsimony phylogenetic trees (Figures
This species is characterised by its large basidiome (up to 200 mm), the indusium reaching 2/3 of the basidiome, the purplish volva and rhizomorphs and the thimble-like and strongly reticulated receptacle.
BRAZIL. Amazonas: Manaus (3.0615S, 60.0111W), 27 February 2014, Cabral TS (UFRN-Fungos 2808). GenBank accessions: MG678487 (ITS), MG678456 (nuc-LSU), MG678542 (atp6).
Immature basidiomes whitish (N60A60M50) with purplish pigments (A10M10C10), globose to subglobose, up to 56 × 43 mm, growing gregariously. Fresh expanded basidiome up to 200 mm high. Receptacle up to 45 × 29 mm, thimble-like, flat at the apex with an apical pore; strongly reticulated surface, shallow reticulations up to 3.2 × 1.7 mm, white (N00A00M00). Pseudostipe up to 122 × 21 mm, cylindrical, spongy, white (N00A00M00); pseudoparenchymatous, composed of globose to elongate-ovoid cells, 37–65.5 × 22.5–48 µm, hyaline. Indusium well-developed, extending up to 2/3 of the pseudostipe, white (N00A00M00), up to 100 mm in length, attached to the apex of the pseudostipe; polygonal meshes up to 10 × 5 mm. Volva semi-hypogeous, white (N00A00M00) becoming purplish (A10M10C10) when exposed, with a smooth surface; formed by filamentous hyphae, septate, branched, hyaline, clamp connections present, 3.1–6.6 μm diameter; with crystal deposits in globose cells widely distributed amongst the hyphae, 17.5–38 × 20.5–35.7 μm. Rhizomorphs composed of at least two types of hyphae: filamentous thin-walled hyphae, with clamp connections; and thicker hyphae (3–6.5 µm) that seem to communicate with each other by pores on the inflated tips. Gleba olive-brown (N99A50M10), mucilaginous. Basidiospores cylindrical, smooth, 4.4–5 × 2.5–3.4 µm, hyaline in 5% KOH.
Phallus purpurascens SINOP27, paratype. A Fresh basidiome B gregarious immature basidiome, with purplish pigments on surface C longitudinal section of an immature basidiome, showing the purplish volva and rhizomorphs. Phallus purpurascens UFRN-Fungos 2808, holotype. D Spores E rhizomorphs hyphae F pseudoparenchymatous hyphae from pseudostipe G hyphae from volva H crystals in globose cells found on volva. Scale bars: 20 mm (A–C), 20 µm (C–H).
on soil, in a fragment of upland secondary forest. It was found in the municipalities of Manaus (State of Amazonas, Brazil) and Sinop (State of Mato Grosso, Brazil).
with reference to the volva becoming purple.
Mato Grosso: Sinop, Parque Florestal de Sinop (11.8359S, 55.5008W), 7 November 2013, Cabral TS (SINOP26, SINOP27, SINOP28, SINOP30).
This species is the most distinctive amongst our collections, mainly due to its large basidiome, the purplish volva and rhizomorphs and the strongly reticulated receptacle. Phallus rubrovolvatus (M. Zang, D.G. Ji & X.X. Liu) Kreisel is one of the largest white-indusiate species (up to 330 mm); it differs from P. purpurascens by the deep red volva, the fragile indusium, by larger reticulations on the receptacle and smaller spores (3.7–4 × 2–2.5 µm) (
Phallus purpurascens was found in a fragment of secondary forest, in an extremely threatened area of the Amazonian forest domain in the State of Mato Grosso, Brazil. This state was the second most deforested in Brazil in 2018 (
This species is characterised by its immature basidiome and volva with a squamous surface, white receptacle with shallow reticulations and a wide pore.
BRAZIL. Rio Grande do Norte: Baía Formosa, Reserva Particular do Patrimônio Natural Mata Estrela (6.383307S, 35.000365W), 27 February 2014, Silva BDB (UFRN-Fungos 2806). GenBank accessions: MG678497 (ITS), MG678547 (atp6).
Immature basidiomes whitish (N60A60M50), up to 39 × 34 mm, ovoid, with squamous surface. Fresh expanded basidiome up to 95 mm high. Receptacle 20 × 28 mm, campanulate to thimble-like, with a wide apical pore; and a strongly but shallow reticulated surface, reticulations 1.6–2 × 0.8–1.2 mm. Pseudostipe 60 × 12 mm, cylindrical, spongy, white (N00A00M00); pseudoparenchymatous, composed of globose to elongate-ovoid cells, 18–71 × 10.5–35 µm, hyaline. Indusium well-developed, extending to 2/3 of pseudostipe, white (N00A00M00), 44 mm in length, attached to the apex of the pseudostipe; polygonal to rounded meshes up to 6 × 3 mm. Volva epigeous, whitish (N00A00M00) to pale yellow (N00C00A30), with squamous surface; formed by filamentous hyphae, septate, branched, hyaline, clamp connections present, 2.5–4.5 μm diameter. Rhizomorphs whitish (N00A00M00), composed of filamentous thin-walled hyphae, with clamp connections; with crystal deposits in globose cells distributed amongst the hyphae, 15–17.9 × 14–17 μm. Gleba olive-brown (N99A50M10), mucilaginous. Basidiospores elongated, smooth, 3.5–4.4 × 1.8–2.2 µm, hyaline in 5% KOH.
found growing on sandy soil, in a fragment of ombrophilous forest in the Atlantic Rainforest domain.
with reference to the volva covered with small scales.
Only one specimen of this species has been found to date in the northern Atlantic Rainforest domain, but it is quite distinct from other species found in this study. We could not find white-indusiate species records with squamous exoperidium in the available literature. However, P. duplicatus, described in
≡ Dictyophora indusiata (Vent.) Desv., J. Bot., Paris 2: 92 (1809)
≡ Hymenophallus indusiatus (Vent.) Nees, Syst. Pilze (Würzburg): 251 (1816)
= Dictyophora indusiata f. rosea (Ces.) Kobayasi, J. Jap. Bot. 40: 180 (1965)
= Dictyophora indusiata f. callichroa (Möller) Kobayasi, Trans. Mycol. Soc. Japan 6: 6 (1965)
= Hymenophallus roseus Ces., Atti Accad. Sci. fis. mat. Napoli 8(8): 12 (1879)
= Hymenophallus duplicatus (Bosc) Nees, Syst. Pilze (Würzburg): 251 (1816)
= Phallus duplicatus Bosc, Mag. Gesell. naturf. Freunde, Berlin 5: 86 (1811)
= Dictyophora duplicata (Bosc) E. Fisch., in Berlese, De Toni & Fischer, Syll. fung. (Abellini) 7(1): 6 (1888)
= Dictyophora rosea (Ces.) E. Fisch., in Saccardo, Syll. fung. (Abellini) 7(1): 6 (1888)
= Dictyophora phalloidea var. rosea (Ces.) Lloyd, Synopsis of the known phalloids 7: 20 (1909)
= Dictyophora phalloidea var. callichroa (Möller) Lloyd, Synopsis of the known phalloids 7: 20 (1909)
= Dictyophora callichroa Möller, Bot. Mitt. Trop. 7: 129, 148 (1895)
≡ Phallus callichrous (Möller) Lloyd, Mycol. Writ. 7: 6 (1907)
= Phallus indusiatus var. rochesterensis (Lloyd) Lloyd, Synopsis of the known phalloids 7: 81 (1909)
= Phallus rochesterensis Lloyd, Synopsis of the known phalloids 7: 20 (1909)
= Dictyophora phalloidea var. rochesterensis (Lloyd) Sacc. & Trotter, Syll. fung. (Abellini) 21: 460 (1912)
= Dictyophora indusiata f. aurantiaca Kobayasi, Nov. fl. jap. 2: 83 (1938)
= Phallus indusiatus f. citrinus K. Das, S.K. Singh & Calonge, Boln Soc. Micol. Madrid 31: 136 (2007)
(designated here): BRAZIL. Pará: Belterra, Floresta Nacional do Tapajós, Jamaraqua Community (2.812667S, 55.033083W), 25 March 2014, Cabral TS (INPA-Fungos 264931). GenBank accessions: MG678500, MG678501, MG678502 (ITS); MG678463 (nuc-LSU); MG678550 (atp6).
Immature basidiomes not observed. Fresh expanded basidiome 120 mm high. Receptacle 25 × 25 mm, campanulate, with an apical pore, reticulated surface. Pseudostipe 67 × 12 mm, cylindrical, spongy, white (N00A00M00); pseudoparenchymatous, composed of globose to elongate-ovoid cells, 29.5–56.8 × 17.2–44 µm, hyaline. Indusium in full development extending to the ground, white (N00A00M00), 74 mm in length, attached to the apex of the pseudostipe; polygonal to rounded meshes up to 7 × 4 mm, composed of pseudoparenchymatous cells, 31–53.8 × 23.8–41 µm. Volva hypogeous, white (N00A00M0), with pinkish pigments (N00M10C00); outer layer papery, composed of filamentous hyphae, 3.22–6.5 µm, yellowish, septate, with clamp connections; crystal deposits in globose cells distributed amongst the hyphae, 11.5–13.8 × 19.6–22.7 μm. Rhizomorphs composed of filamentous thin-walled hyphae, with clamp connections. Gleba olive-brown (N99A50M10), mucilaginous. Basidiospores elongated, smooth, 3.6–4.1 × 1.5–2.2 µm, hyaline in 5% KOH.
Phallus indusiatus. Fresh basidiome of A INPA-Fungos 264931 (neotype), and B INPA-Fungos 264929, showing the volva with pinkish pigments C spores D pseudoparenchymatous hyphae from pseudostipe E hyphae from volva and crystals deposits on globose cells F hyphae from rhizomorphs. Scale bars: 20 mm (A, B); 10 µm (C); 40 µm (D); 20 µm (E, F).
found on sandy soil, in dense old-growth forest. It has a questionable circum-tropical distribution, with records for South and Central America, Mexico, Africa, Asia and Australia, but we believe that the distribution is restricted to South America.
BRAZIL. Pará: Belterra, Floresta Nacional do Tapajós, Jamaraqua Community (2.812667S, 55.033083W), 25 March 2014, Cabral TS (INPA-Fungos 264929, INPA-Fungos 264930); São Paulo, Parque Estadual das Fontes do Ipiranga (23.54S, 46.63W), January 2011, Oliveira, J.J.S. (SP416389); March 2011, Ventura, P.O. (SP416393); Capelari, M. (SP416087).
According to Ventenat’s original description, P. indusiatus is characterised by the hypogeous volva, the campanulate and reticulated receptacle and by the indusium reaching the ground. The indusium is white, but it can become reddish as it matures. Ventenat does not give information on the colour of the volva and rhizomorphs, but some authors state that the volva can be light pinkish and rhizomorphs can be pinkish to violet (
Molecular and morphological analyses, as well as geographical distributions, support the description of three new species within the Phallus indusiatus-like specimens from Brazil, with partially overlapping distributions. Our results suggest that a great number of species might be hidden within the circum-tropical P. indusiatus species concept, since the sequence data obtained from GenBank are clearly polyphyletic with different relationships with other Phallus species (Figures
Regarding the Brazilian indusiate clade, we suggest that species within this group are, in fact, divergent entities that maintained the general ancestral phenotype (P. indusiatus s.l.) throughout their evolutionary history, due to high levels of morphological stasis. This would explain the high frequency of taxonomic uncertainties, which generates a great number of synonyms of P. indusiatus. The maintenance of a conserved morphology due to low rates of phenotypic variation has been widely discussed in evolution (
When studying phalloid species, it is noticeable that macro-characters are more variable than micro-characters. For instance, spores are often cylindrical to bacilloid and smooth throughout the order (except for Gastrosporiaceae), probably as an adaptation for dispersal, since they are dispersed through the gut and do not adhere on the bodies of insects (
On the other hand, macro-characters, such as the shape, surface and colour of the main structures (receptacle, pseudostipe, indusium, volva and rhizomorphs), are important characters for infrageneric classification (
Morphological differences between the new Phallus species described here and Phallus indusiatus.
Phallus denigricans | Phallus purpurascens | Phallus squamulosus | Phallus indusiatus | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Basidiome development | Epigeous | Partially epigeous | Epigeous | Initially hypogeous |
Receptacle | Constricted at the base, pale yellow, prominent apical pore | Conical, thimble-like, flat at the apex, white, strongly reticulated, with an apical pore | Campanulate to thimble-like, with a wide apical pore, strongly reticulated surface | Campanulate, white, reticulated, with an apical pore |
Indusium | Extending to 2/3 of pseudostipe, poorly developed | Extending to 2/3 of pseudostipe, well developed |
Extending to 2/3 of pseudostipe, well developed |
Fully developed, extending to the ground |
Volva | White to blackish, smooth surface or with projections, epigeous | White, becoming purplish, smooth surface, semi-hypogeous | Whitish to pale yellow, squamous surface, epigeous | White, pinkish pigments, hypogeous |
Crystal deposits | Found on both volva and rhizomorphs of white volva specimens | Found on volva | Found on rhizomorphs | Found on volva |
Basidiospores | Elongated, 3.6–4.6 × 2.2–2.5 µm | Cylindrical, 4.4–5 × 2.5–3.4 µm | Elongated, 3.5–4.4 × 1.8–2.2 µm | Elongated, 3.6–4.1 × 1.5–2.2 µm |
The authors wish to thank the Brazilian funding agencies Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq 473422/2012-3, 160321/2013-1 and 458210/2014-5) and Fundação de Amparo a Pesquisa do Estado do Amazonas (FAPEAM 3137/2012) for grant awards and Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES 7296/14-2) and Ministério da Ciência, Tecnologia, Inovação e Comunicação (303851/2015-5) for scholarships. We thank Dr. Doriane Picanço Rodrigues for coordination of the Laboratory of Applied Evolution at the Federal University of Amazonas, where part of the molecular data was obtained. We are grateful to Ricardo Braga Neto and Dirce Leimi Komura for collecting support.
Table S1
Data type: species data
Figure S1
Data type: phylogenetic tree
Figure S2
Data type: phylogenetic tree