Research Article |
Corresponding author: J. Jennifer Luangsa-ard ( jajen@biotec.or.th ) Academic editor: Thorsten Lumbsch
© 2020 Wilawan Kuephadungphan, Kanoksri Tasanathai, Booppa Petcharad, Artit Khonsanit, Marc Stadler, J. Jennifer Luangsa-ard.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kuephadungphan W, Tasanathai K, Petcharad B, Khonsanit A, Stadler M, Luangsa-ard JJ (2020) Phylogeny- and morphology-based recognition of new species in the spider-parasitic genus Gibellula (Hypocreales, Cordycipitaceae) from Thailand. MycoKeys 72: 17-42. https://doi.org/10.3897/mycokeys.72.55088
|
Thailand is known to be a part of what is called the Indo-Burma biodiversity hotspot, hosting a vast array of organisms across its diverse ecosystems. This is reflected by the increasing number of new species described over time, especially fungi. However, a very few fungal species from the specialized spider-parasitic genus Gibellula have ever been reported from this region. A survey of invertebrate-pathogenic fungi in Thailand over several decades has led to the discovery of a number of fungal specimens with affinities to this genus. Integration of morphological traits into multi-locus phylogenetic analysis uncovered four new species: G. cebrennini, G. fusiformispora, G. pigmentosinum, and G. scorpioides. All these appear to be exclusively linked with torrubiella-like sexual morphs with the presence of granulomanus-like asexual morph in G. pigmentosinum and G. cebrennini. A remarkably high host specificity of these new species towards their spider hosts was revealed, and for the first time, evidence is presented for manipulation of host behavior in G. scorpioides.
Cordycipitaceae, Gibellula, spider specialist fungus, taxonomy
To arthropodologists or even arachnologists, it is surprising that fungal pathogens of spiders seem to be generally neglected when the host can be completely overgrown by the pathogens to be unrecognizable as a spider. Nonetheless, this group of fungi has been known and studied for more than two centuries (
Gibellula is well-known to be a specialized spider-parasitic genus widely distributed worldwide, mostly found in tropical regions (
Thailand is one of the most biodiverse countries in Southeast Asia and the BIOTEC culture collection has more than 700 Gibellula strains. Despite this number, only very few Gibellula species with distinct features could be recognized morphologically (
Our continuous survey of invertebrate-pathogenic fungi in Thailand for over two decades has led to the BIOTEC Bangkok Herbarium (BBH) and the BIOTEC Culture Collection (BCC) owning a very large herbaria, and culture collections, which greatly facilitates the exploration of existing species including Gibellula. Here, phylogeny within Gibellula species from the ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions analyzed prior to this study enabled recognition of four distinct clades. The morphological and multi-gene phylogenetic data confirm their identities as well as taxonomic placements. Herein, new species are described that are illustrated morphologically and phylogenetically and compared with other species in the same genus.
Spiders parasitized by Gibellula spp. firmly attached on the underside of living leaves were collected from various locations throughout Thailand, mostly in the Northeastern region. The leaf bearing the parasitized spider was carefully detached from the tree, placed in a plastic box and transported to the laboratory for immediate isolation of a pure culture according to the protocols described by
Microscopic characteristics were studied based on observation of synnemata and perithecia. Each of them was detached from the stroma and mounted on a microscope slide containing a drop of lactophenol cotton blue solution. Shapes and sizes of individual character were determined and measured according to
The mummified spiders were identified based on morphological characteristics. To better understand the host-pathogen relationship, posture of spider at attachment on leaf surface (touching or lifting), position of spider on the leaf (under or upper side), and leaf type (monocots or dicots) were herein recorded.
DNA extraction, PCR amplification of five DNA regions as well as purification of PCR products were conducted according to the protocols previously described by
DNA sequences were checked manually for ambiguous base calls and all sequences were assembled using BioEdit v.7.2.5 (
Phylogenetic relationships were inferred using maximum likelihood (ML) with GTRCAT as the substitution model in RAXML 7.2.8 (
The combined data set of 43 taxa (Table
List of taxa included in the phylogenetic analysis and their GenBank accession numbers. The isolates representing four new species and other sequences generated in this study are marked in bold.
Species | Code | GenBank accession numbers | References | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ITS | LSU | TEF1 | RPB1 | RPB2 | |||
Akanthomyces aculeatus | HUA 772 | KC519371 | KC519370 | KC519366 | – | – |
|
A. aculeatus | HUA 186145 | – | MF416520 | MF416465 | – | – |
|
A. sabanensis | ANDES-F 1014 | KC633245 | KC633248 | KC875221 | – | – |
|
A. sabanensis | ANDES-F 1024T | KC633232 | KC875225 | KC633266 | – | KC633249 |
|
Beauveria bassiana | ARSEF 7518 | HQ880762 | – | HQ880975 | HQ880834 | HQ880906 |
|
B. bassiana | ARSEF 1564T | NR111594 | – | HQ880974 | HQ880833 | HQ880905 |
|
Cordyceps militaris | OSC 93623 | JN049825 | AY184966 | DQ522332 | DQ522377 | AY545732 |
|
C. militaris | ARSEF 5050 | HQ880829 | – | HQ881020 | HQ880901 | HQ880973 |
|
C. farinosa | CBS 111113T | AY624181 | MF416554 | MF416499 | MF416656 | MF416450 |
|
C. javanica | CBS 134.22T | NR111172 | NG059048 | MF416504 | MF416661 | MF416455 |
|
C. javanica | BCC 26304 | MH532851 | MH394660 | MH521903 | MH521825 | MH521868 |
|
Blackwellomyces cardinalis | OSC 93609T | – | AY184962 | DQ522325 | DQ522370 | DQ522422 |
|
B. cardinalis | OSC 93610 | JN049843 | AY184963 | EF469059 | EF469088 | EF469106 |
|
Engyodontium aranearum | CBS 309.85 | JN036556 | AF339526 | DQ522341 | DQ522387 | DQ522439 |
|
E. aranearum | CBS 658.80 | LC092897 | LC092916 | – | – | – |
|
Hevansia novoguineensis | CBS 610.80T | MH532831 | MH394646 | MH521885 | – | MH521844 |
|
H. novoguineensis | NHJ 4314 | – | – | EU369012 | EU369051 | EU369071 |
|
H. novoguineensis | NHJ 11923 | – | EU369032 | EU369013 | EU369052 | EU369072 |
|
H. novoguineensis | BCC 47881 | JX192685 | MH394650 | MH521886 | MH521807 | MH521845 |
|
H. cinerea | NHJ 3510 | – | – | EU369009 | EU369048 | EU369070 |
|
Gibellula cf. alba | NHJ 11679 | – | – | EU369016 | EU369054 | – |
|
G. cebrennini | BCC 32072 | MT477067 | – | MT503326 | – | – | This study |
G. cebrennini | BCC 39705 | MH532874 | MH394673 | MH521895 | MH521822 | MH521859 | This study |
G. cebrennini | BCC 53551 | MT477068 | – | MT503327 | – | – | This study |
G. cebrennini | BCC 53605T | MT477069 | MT477062 | MT503328 | MT503321 | MT503336 | This study |
G clavulifera var. alba | ARSEF 1915T | – | DQ518777 | DQ522360 | DQ522408 | DQ522467 |
|
G. fusiformispora | BCC 45076 | MH532882 | – | – | MH521823 | MH521860 | This study |
G. fusiformispora | BCC 56802T | MT477070 | MT477063 | MT503329 | MT503322 | MT503337 | This study |
G. gamsii | BCC 27968T | MH152529 | MH152539 | MH152560 | MH152547 | – |
|
G. gamsii | BCC 28797 | MH152531 | MH152541 | MH152562 | MH152549 | MH152557 |
|
G leiopus | BCC 16025 | – | MF416548 | MF416492 | MF416649 | – |
|
G longispora | NHJ 12014 | – | – | EU369017 | EU369055 | EU369075 |
|
G pulchra | NHJ 10808 | – | EU369035 | EU369018 | EU369056 | EU369076 |
|
G. pigmentosinum | BCC 38246 | MH532872 | MH394672 | MH521893 | MH521800 | MH521855 |
|
G. pigmentosinum | BCC 39707 | MH532875 | MH394674 | MH521894 | MH521801 | MH521856 |
|
G. pigmentosinum | BCC 41203T | MT477071 | – | MT503330 | MT503323 | – | This study |
G. pigmentosinum | BCC 41870 | MT477072 | MT477064 | MT503331 | MT503324 | – | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 13020 | MT477073 | MH394686 | MH521901 | MH521814 | – | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 43298 | MT477074 | MH394677 | MH521900 | MH521816 | MH521858 | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 45127 | MT477075 | – | MT503332 | – | – | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 47514 | MT477076 | – | MT503333 | – | – | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 47530 | MT477077 | MT477065 | MT503334 | – | MT503338 | This study |
G. scorpioides | BCC 47976T | MT477078 | MT477066 | MT503335 | MT503325 | MT503339 | This study |
Phylogenetic tree inferred from a RAxML search of a concatenated alignment of ITS, LSU, TEF1, RPB1 and RPB2 showing the relationship among Gibellula and related genera. Bootstrap proportions/ Bayesian posterior probabilities ≥ 50% are provided above corresponding nodes; nodes with 100% support are shown as thick lines. The ex-type strains are marked with a superscript T (T) and the isolates reported in this study are bold.
Thailand, Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Mo Sing To Nature Trail; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Cebrenninus cf. magnus (Thomisidae, Araneae) attached to the underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 20 June 2012; K. Tasanathai, S. Mongkolsamrit, A. Khonsanit, W. Noisripoom, P. Srikitikulchai, K. Sansatchanon, R. Somnuk (Holotype no. BBH 35749, ex-type culture no. BCC 53604, isolated from ascospores and BCC 53605, isolated from conidia). GenBank (BCC 53605): ITS = MT477069, LSU = MT477062, TEF1 = MT503328, RPB1 = MT503321, RPB2 = MT503336.
Refers to its spider host.
Synnema arising from white to cream mycelial mat completely covering the spider host, cylindric, white to cream, slightly enlarged toward the sterile tip, consisting of multiseptate somewhat loosely bound longitudinal hyphae (Fig.
Gibellula cebrennini a fungus on spider (BBH 35749) b perithecia c a part of synnema showing conidiophores d perithecium e asci with apical apparatus f ascospores g conidiophore h conidial head i conidia j granulomanus-like asexual morph k colonies obverse and reverse on PDA at 25 °C after 28 days. Scale bars: 1 mm (d); 50 μm (e–f, g); 20 μm (h, j); 10 μm (i).
Colonies derived from conidia, on PDA slow-growing, attaining a diam of 1.4±0.05 cm in 4 weeks at 25 °C, white, velvety; reverse cream, becoming light brown with age toward center (Fig.
Thailand, Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Kong Kaeo Waterfall; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Araneida, underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 28 November 2006; K. Tasanathai, W. Chaygate, B. Thongnuch (BBH 18890, BCC 23863); Mo Sing To Nature Trail; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Cebrenninus cf. magnus, underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 18 June 2008; J. Luangsa-ard, K. Tasanathai, S. Mongkolsamrit, B. Thongnuch, P. Srikitikulchai, R. Ridkaew, W. Chaygate, R. Promharn (BBH 24673, BCC 32072). On Cebrenninus cf. magnus, underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 11 September 2009; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, T. Chohmee, R. Ridkaew (BBH 32685, BCC 39705 and BCC 39706). On Cebrenninus cf. magnus, underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 6 June 2012; K. Tasanathai, S. Mongkolsamrit, A. Khonsanit, W. Noisripoom, P. Srikitikulchai (BBH 32589, BCC 53551).
Thailand, Chiang Mai, Chiang Dao District, Ban Huathung; 19°420'N, 98°971'E; on Araneida attached to the underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 5 October 2012; K. Tasanathai, A. Khonsanit, W. Noisripoom, P. Srikitikulchai, R. Promharn (Holotype no. BBH 32918, ex-type culture no. BCC 56802, isolated from conidia) GenBank: ITS = MT477070, LSU = MT477063, TEF1 = MT503329, RPB1 = MT503322, RPB2 = MT503337.
Refers to the fusiform part-spores.
Spiders totally covered by the white to cream mycelial mat. A single synnema or synnemata in pairs cream to light brown, often darker than the mycelia covering the host, narrowing toward the apex and terminating in a swollen sterile tip with acute apex (Fig.
Gibellula fusiformispora a fungus on a spider (BBH 38838) b fungus on a spider (BBH 32918) c synnemata (BBH 32918) d, e perithecia (BBH 38838) f ascus (BBH 38838) g ascospores (BBH 38838) h conidia (BBH 32918) i conidiophores showing conidial heads (BBH 32918) j conidial head bearing conidia (BCC 32918) k colonies obverse and reverse on PDA at 25 °C after 20 days. Scale bars: 250 μm (e); 100 μm (i); 50 μm (g); 20 μm (f, h, j).
Colonies derived from conidia, on PDA slow-growing, attaining a diam of 1.1±0.03 cm in 20 days at 25 °C, white, velvety; reverse cream, becoming light brown with age toward center (Fig.
Thailand, Chiang Mai, Chiang Dao District, Ban Huathung; 19°420'N, 98°971'E; on Deinopidae (Araneae) attached to the underside of unidentified monocot leaf; 23 September 2010; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, A. Khonsanit, K. Sansatchanon (BBH 38838, BCC 45076 and BCC 45077).
The sexual morph of G. fusiformispora is extremely close to Torrubiella ellipsoidea (
Thailand. Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Mo Sing To Nature Trail; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Storenomorpha sp., attached to underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 10 February 2010; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, T. Chohmee, R. Ridkaew, A. Khonsanit (Holotype no. BBH 28509, ex-type culture no. BCC 41203, isolated from ascospores and BCC 41204, isolated from conidia). GenBank (BCC 41203): ITS = MT477071, TEF1 = MT503330, RPB1 = MT503323.
Refers to the capability of the fungus to produce pigmentosins.
Spider host completely covered by white to yellowish-white mycelial mat. Synnemata solitary or in pairs, cylindrical, white, becoming yellowish-white at the base (Fig.
Gibellula pigmentosinum a fungus on spider (BBH 28509); b perithecia; c an ascus with an apical apparatus; d ascospore; e part-spores; f conidiophores; g conidial heads; h conidia; i granulomanus-like asexual morph; j colonies obverse and reverse on PDA at 25 °C after 28 days. Scale bars: 1 mm (b); 500 μm (d); 100 μm (f); 50 μm (g); 20 μm (c, i); 10 μm (e, h).
Colonies derived from ascospores, on PDA slow-growing, attaining a diam of 1.5±0.2 cm in 4 weeks at 25 °C, white, floccose; reverse light brown, darkening with age toward center (Fig.
Additional specimens examined. Thailand, Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Mo Sing To Nature Trail; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Storenomorpha sp., underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 13 August 2009; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, T. Chohmee, R. Ridkaew (BBH 26516, BCC 38246 and BCC 38955); on Araneida, underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 11 September 2009; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, T. Chohmee, R. Ridkaew (BBH 27081, BCC 39707 and BCC 39708); on Storenomorpha sp., underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 7 April 2010; K. Tasanathai, S. Mongkolsamrit, T. Chohmee, A. Khonsanit, R. Ridkaew (BBH 28533, BCC 41870 and BCC 41871).
Gibellula pigmentosinum shares similarity with G pulchra (
Thailand, Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Mo Sing To Nature Trail, 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Portia sp. attached to the underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 1 June 2011; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, A. Khonsanit, K. Sansatchanon, W. Noisripoom (Holotype no. BBH 31439, ex-type culture no. BCC 47975, isolated from ascospores and BCC 47976, isolated from conidia) GenBank (BCC 47976): ITS = MT477078, LSU = MT477066, TEF1 = MT503335, RPB1 = MT503325, RPB2 = MT503339.
Refers to the outer appearance of the fungus resembling the posture of a scorpion.
White to grayish- or brownish-white mycelial mat velvety, completely covering the spider host, firmly attaching the underside of living leaf by the mycelia covering its legs (Fig.
Gibellula scorpioides a fungus on a spider (BBH 29669) b fungus on a spider (BBH 31439) c perithecia (BBH 31439) d conidiophores arising on synnema (BBH 29669) e penicillate conidiophore (BBH 29669) f conidia (BBH 29669) g asci (BBH 31439) h ascus with apical apparatus (BBH 31439) i ascospores (BBH 31439) j penicillate conidiophore produced on PDA k conidia on PDA l colonies obverse and reverse on PDA at 25 °C after 4 months. Scale bars: 500 μm (c); 50 μm (d, g); 20 μm (e, h–j); 10 μm (f, k).
Colonies derived from conidia, on PDA slow-growing, attaining a diam of 1.5±0.1 cm in 4 weeks at 25 °C, floccose, forming irregular margin, white, reverse cream, darkening toward center with age (Fig.
Additional specimens examined. Thailand, Chumphon, Phato District, Phato Watershed Conservation and Management Unit; 9°784'N, 98°699'E; on Portia sp., underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 10 March 2011; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, A. Khonsanit, K. Sansatchanon, D. Thanakitpipattana (BBH 30499, BCC 47530). Nakhon Ratchasima, Khao Yai National Park, Mo Sing To Nature Trail; 14°711'N, 101°421'E; on Portia sp., underside of unidentified dicot leaf; 1 June 2011; K. Tasanathai, P. Srikitikulchai, S. Mongkolsamrit, A. Khonsanit, K. Sansatchanon, W. Noisripoom (BBH 29669, BCC 43298).
The morphology of G. scorpioides appeared to be very close to G clavulifera var. clavulifera (
A torrubiella-like sexual morph is well-known to be connected with Gibellula (
The morphological resemblance between G. cebrennini and G. fusiformispora as well as a multi-gene phylogenetic analysis indicate a very close relationship among these species. Moreover, they can be distinguished from each other by the length of conidiophores, the shape of ascospores as well as the presence of a granulomanus-like conidial state.
In nature, a torrubiella-like sexual morph may occur on spider hosts without the presence of Gibellula. It may be premature to assign the new species to Gibellula on the basis of sexual morph, when more than one asexually reproductive genus are known to be linked to a torrubiella-like sexual morph. Gibellula cebrennini and Akanthomyces thailandicus (
It has been over a half century since host specialization was suggested as one of the taxonomic criteria for parasitic fungi (
According to the effort of putting toward species identification of spider hosts (
It is notable that all seven host individuals used for identification in this study were found under a leaf. Portia sp. has a unique life history. These spiders are not only web invaders or cursorial hunters but are also web builders. Thus, they exist both on and off their own webs. Their webs are used for various activities including trapping, baiting, resting, molting, mating, oviposition, brooding (
Since G. scorpioides can be cultured, it is possible to apply fungal spores to Portia spiders and study the spider-fungus interaction. It will be particularly interesting to investigate death sites, on or off web and death posture, resting or hunting postures between uninfected control and fungal infected spiders, which may give insight into behavioural manipulation before death by the fungus. Additionally, cultured G. scorpioides could be used to test the antifungal properties of Portia spider silk.
It is remarkable that our finding has revealed the high possibility to incorporate the host specificity in molecular and morphological criteria for classification and identification of Gibellula.
The biggest challenge for molecular phylogeny-based classification of Gibellula is the lack of reliable sequence data from type specimens. From sequences available in public databases, identities often appear erroneous, e.g. G. clavispora (
Despite molecular phylogeny currently being the most powerful approach available in modern fungal classification and taxonomy (
This work was supported by the National Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (BIOTEC) Platform Technology Management (Grant no. P19-50231), National Science and Technology Development Agency (NSTDA). This project has also received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Staff Exchange (RISE) programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 645701, Project acronym “GoMyTri”; lead beneficiaries JJL and MS. The National Park, Wildlife and Plant Conservation Department in Thailand is gratefully acknowledged for permission to conduct a study in the protected area. We are grateful to Dr. Philip James Shaw for the English editing and the reviewers whose comments and suggestions helped improve our manuscript.