Research Article |
Corresponding author: Julia Kruse ( julia.kruse1@gmx.de ) Academic editor: Thorsten Lumbsch
© 2018 Julia Kruse, Volker Kummer, Roger G. Shivas, Marco Thines.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kruse J, Kummer V, Shivas RG, Thines M (2018) The first smut fungus, Thecaphora anthemidis sp. nov. (Glomosporiaceae), described from Anthemis (Asteraceae). MycoKeys 41: 39-50. https://doi.org/10.3897/mycokeys.41.28454
|
There are 63 known species of Thecaphora (Glomosporiaceae, Ustilaginomycotina), a third of which occur on Asteraceae. These smut fungi produce yellowish-brown to reddish-brown masses of spore balls in specific, mostly regenerative, plant organs. A species of Thecaphora was collected in the flower heads of Anthemis chia (Anthemideae, Asteraceae) on Rhodes Island, Greece, in 2015 and 2017, which represents the first smut record of a smut fungus on a host plant species in this tribe. Based on its distinctive morphology, host species and genetic divergence, this species is described as Thecaphora anthemidis sp. nov. Molecular barcodes of the ITS region are provided for this and several other species of Thecaphora. A phylogenetic and morphological comparison to closely related species showed that Th. anthemidis differed from other species of Thecaphora. Thecaphora anthemidis produced loose spore balls in the flower heads and peduncles of Anthemis chia unlike other flower-infecting species.
Glomosporiaceae , host specificity, internal transcribed spacer, molecular phylogenetics, smut fungi
Thecaphora species belong to the Glomosporiaceae (Urocystidales, Ustilaginomycotina). The type species is Th. seminis-convolvuli described from Convolvulus arvensis (Convolvulaceae) collected in France (Desmazièrs 1827). Until now, 63 species of Thecaphora have been recognised (
The Asteraceae is the largest family of eudicots with an estimated number of 30,000 species (
About 20 species of Thecaphora infect host plant species in six tribes of the Asteraceae. Taxa of the tribes Astereae and Heliantheae in the subfamily Asteroideae are often hosts of several Thecaphora species. Some less species-rich tribes, e.g. Coreopsideae, Millerieae, Polymnieae and Cynareae (subfamily Carduoideae) are also hosts of Thecaphora species. The species of Thecaphora on Asteraceae have not been studied by molecular phylogenetic methods, in contrast to species of Thecaphora on Caryophyllaceae (
Plants of Anthemis chia with distorted flower heads containing mostly ligulate (ray) florets and swollen peduncles were collected near Tsambika, Rhodes Island, Greece, in 2015 and 2017. The swollen flower heads contained reddish-brown granular to powdery spore ball masses, typical of species of Thecaphora. The aim of this study was to identify the fungus and to determine its taxonomic assignment based on morphological and phylogenetic analyses of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS, barcoding locus) sequence data.
Herbarium specimens (23) of Thecaphora on a range of host plant species from across Europe and North America were examined (Tables
The morphology of the spore balls and spores of one specimen (
Genomic DNA was extracted from 23 herbarium specimens of Thecaphora (Table
In total, 42 ITS sequences from 21 Thecaphora species were used in the phylogenetic analyses. Sequences were aligned with MAFFT v.7 (
Species | Host | Country | Location | Date | Collector | Herbarium accession no.* |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Thecaphora affinis | Astragalus glycyphyllos | Slovenia | Lower Styria, region Savinjska, N of Ljubno ob Savinjii, trail to Mt. Greben Smrekovec-Komen from Primož pri Ljubnem, wayside, 46°24'21"N, 14°49'54"E, 1150 m asl | 14 July 2015 | J. Kruse |
|
A. glycyphyllos | Germany | Saxony-Anhalt, SW of Zschornewitz, forestry trail nearby SW-shore of „Gürke“ (Zschornewitzer Lake) | 26 June 2007 | H. Jage |
|
|
Th. anthemidis | Anthemis chia | Greece | Island Rhodes, 3.5 km NE Archangelos, Tsambika, way up to monastery, northeastslope, 36°14'03"N, 28°09'19"E, 90 m asl | 26 April 2017 | V. Kummer |
|
Th. haumanii | Iresine diffusa | Costa Rica | Prov. Guanacaste, 6 km NW de la barrada de la Laguna de Arenal | 1 April 1992 | R. Berndt, M. Piepenbring | M 0236177 |
Th. leptideum | Chenopodium album | France | Lotharingia, Forbach, Kreuzberg Mt. | Aug.-Oct. 1912/1913 | A. Ludwig | M 0230099 |
Th. molluginis | Mollugo cerviana | Romania | Bratovesti, Oltenia | 15 July 1963 | K. Lug. Eliart | M 0236178 |
M. cerviana | Romania | Oltenia, Timburesti | 19 Sept. 1958 | L. Pop | M 0236180 | |
Th. oxalidis | Oxalis stricta | Austria | Upper Austria, Braunau at Inn, Hagenau Inncounty, Hagenauer Street, wayside, 48°16'24"N, 13°06'03"E, 340 m asl | 18 Aug. 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
O. stricta | Germany | Bavaria, Upper Franconia, Fichtelmountains, Fichtelberg, Sandgrubenway, cemetery, 605 m asl | 17 Sept. 2012 | J. Kruse |
|
|
O. stricta | Germany | Saxony-Anhalt, county Anhalt-Bitterfeld, Bitterfeld-Wolfen, Mühlstreet, allotment garden area „Kühler Grund“, 51°37'23"N, 12°20'08"E | 13 July 2014 | J. Kruse & H. Jage |
|
|
Th. pustulata | Bidens pilosa | Puerto Rico, USA | Mayagüez | 13 Mar. 1920 | H. H. Whetzel, E. W. Olive |
|
Th. seminis-convolvuli | Convolvulus arvensis | Germany | Saxony, Middlesaxony, Freiberg, Halsbrücker Street, roadside, 50°55'31"N, 13°20'56"E, 400 m asl | 11 Aug. 2017 | J. Kruse |
|
C. arvensis | Germany | Hesse, c. 8.5 km SE Eschwege, Weißenborn, Sandhöfe, path, 51°07'35"N, 10°07'25"E, 250 m asl | 22 July 2017 | J. Kruse |
|
|
C. arvensis | Germany | Saxony-Anhalt, SSE Seeben, at Franzosenstein, wayside | 26 Aug. 2002 | H. Jage |
|
|
Calystegia sepium | Germany | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, county Vorpommern-Rügen, 1,5 km NE of Barth, Glöwitz, rest area, 54°22'15"N, 12°45'38"E, 0 m asl | 24 Aug. 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
|
C. sepium | Germany | North Rhine-Westphalia, county Steinfurt, Rheine, castle grounds Bentlage, between parking area and Gradierwerk, 52°17'49"N, 07°25'11"E, 35 m asl | 14 July 2017 | J. Kruse |
|
|
Th. seminis-convolvuli | C. sepium | Germany | Schleswig-Holstein, county Schleswig-Flensburg, Schaalby, W of Winningmay, parking area at „Reesholm“, wayside, 54°31'44"N, 09°37'53"E, 2 m asl | 30 Aug. 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
Th. thlaspeos | Arabis ciliata | Austria | Tyrol, district Kufstein, county Walchsee, Kaiserwinkel, track from hickinghut towards Niederkaseralm, over Hintere Abendpoit, eastslope Mt. Hochköpfl, 47°41'25"N, 12°19'37"E, 1300 m asl | 21 July 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
A. ciliata | Germany | Bavaria, Chiemgauer Alps, county Rosenheim, Priener Hut, track 8,20, way up towards Kampenwand, alpine meadow, 47°42'29"N, 12°19'27"E, 1570 m asl | 18 July 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
|
A. ciliata | Germany | Bavaria, Chiemgauer Alps, county Traunstein, Priener Hut, track 8,20 towards Priener Hut, alpine meadow, 47°42'07"N, 12°20'36"E, 1310 m asl | 19 July 2014 | J. Kruse |
|
|
A. hirsuta | Germany | Hesse, Meißnerfoothills, Werra-Meißner-county, Großalmerode, S of Weißenbach, “Bühlchen”, calcareous grassland, 51°14'55"N, 09°51'08"E, 500 m asl | 13 June 2015 | J. Kruse |
|
|
A. hirsuta | Germany | Bavaria, county Donau-Ries, Harburg, N of Ronheim, dry grassland, 435 m asl | 20 June 2013 | J. Kruse |
|
|
A. hirsuta | Germany | Bavaria, Upper Bavaria, county Weilheim, N of Pähl, E at Hartschimmelhof, N „Goaslweide“, wayside, 720 m asl | 20 July 2013 | J. Kruse |
|
Specimens and GenBank sequences used for phylogenetic analyses. Sequences generated in this study are shown in bold.
Thecaphora species | Host | Herbarium accession no. 1 | ITS GenBank accession no. | Reference |
Th. affinis | Astragalus glycyphyllos |
|
MH399748 | this paper |
|
MH399749 | this paper | ||
Th. alsinearum | Stellaria holostea | HUV 10535 | EF200032 |
|
Th. amaranthi | Amaranthus hybridus | HUV 20727 | EF200013 |
|
Th. anthemidis | Anthemis chia |
|
MH399758 | this paper |
Th. frezii | Arachis hypogaea | Sa-EM1* | KP994420 |
|
Cba-GD2* | KP994419 |
|
||
Th. haumanii | Iresine diffusa | M 0236177 | MH399764 | this paper |
Th. hennenea | Melampodium divaricatum | HUV 14434 | EF200014 |
|
Th. italica | Silene italica | HUV 20345 | EF200026 |
|
HUV 20344 | EF200025 |
|
||
Th. leptideum | Chenopodium album | M 0230099 | MH399756 | this paper |
Th. melandrii | Silene alba | HUV 12677 | EF200024 |
|
Th. molluginis | Mollugo cerviana | M 0236178 | MH399762 | this paper |
M 0236180 | MH399763 | this paper | ||
Th. oxalidis | Oxalis stricta |
|
MH399759 | this paper |
|
MH399760 | this paper | ||
|
MH399761 | this paper | ||
Th. oxytropis | Oxytropis pilosa | Kummer P 1146/3* | KF640685 |
|
Kummer P 1146/2* | KF640684 |
|
||
Th. pustulata | Bidens pilosa |
|
MH399757 | this paper |
Th. saponariae | Saponaria officinalis |
|
EF200022 |
|
Th. schwarzmaniana | Rheum ribes |
|
JX006079 |
|
|
KF297811 |
|
||
Th. seminis-convolvuli | Calystegia sepium |
|
MH399742 | this paper |
|
MH399743 | this paper | ||
|
MH399744 | this paper | ||
Convolvulus arvensis |
|
MH399745 | this paper | |
|
MH399746 | this paper | ||
|
MH399747 | this paper | ||
Th. solani | Solanum lycopersicum | HUV 11180 | EF200037 |
|
Th. sp. | Rheum palmatum | S. Wang 1991* | KJ579177 | Piątek et al. unpublished |
Y. Wang 2013* | KJ579176 | Piątek et al. unpublished | ||
HUV 21117 | KF297812 |
|
||
Th. spilanthis | Acmella sp. | AFTOL 1913 | DQ832243 |
|
Th. thlaspeos | Arabis hirsuta |
|
MH399752 | this paper |
|
KJ579178 |
|
||
|
MH399750 | this paper | ||
|
MH399751 | this paper | ||
Arabis ciliata |
|
MH399753 | this paper | |
|
MH399754 | this paper | ||
|
MH399755 | this paper |
The ML and BA trees yielded consistent topologies with the ME tree (Fig.
Phylogenetic tree of Thecaphora species based on ME analysis of the ITS locus. Numbers on branches denote support in ME, ML and BA, respectively. Values below 50% are denoted by ‘–‘. The bar indicates the number of substitutions per site. Ex-type sequences are highlighted with an asterisk.
Greece, Rhodes Island, 3.5 km NE Archangelos, Tsambika, on path to monastery, northeast slope, 36°14'03"N, 28°09'19"E, 90 m a.s.l, on Anthemis chia, 26 Apr. 2017, V. Kummer. Holotype
From the host plant genus Anthemis.
Sori in swollen and distorted flower heads and peduncles; spore ball mass initially white, later reddish-brown, granular to powdery; spore balls subglobose to ellipsoidal, rarely ovoid, mostly regular in shape, (31–) 36–41–47 (–52) × (28–) 31–38–44 (–50) µm, length/width ratio 0.9–1.1–1.2 (n=30), under light microscopy yellowish-brown to pale yellowish-brown, composed of 2–10 (–12) loosely united spores that separate easily; spores ellipsoidal, subglobose, ovoid or cuneiform, (18–) 20–21–23 (–25) × (14–) 17–18–20 (–23) µm, length/width ratio of 1.1–1.2–1.4 (n=100), with flattened contact surfaces and rounded exposed surfaces; wall at contact surface up to 0.5 µm thick, wall at free surface up to 3 µm thick, densely verrucose with warts 0.5–1 µm high, often confluent and sometimes irregular.
Anthemis chia.
Greece.
Thecaphora anthemidis has sori in the flower heads and the peduncles, which differentiates it from the following species that produce pustules, galls or swellings on the stems of Asteraceae: Th. ambrosiae, Th. denticulata, Th. heliopsidis, Th. hennenea, Th. melampodii, Th. mexicana, Th. neomexicana, Th. piluliformis, Th. polymniae, Th. pulcherrima, Th. pustulata, Th. smallanthi and Th. spilanthis. Four of the seven previously known species of Thecaphora that infect the flower heads of Asteraceae, namely Th. arnicae, Th. burkartii, Th. californica and Th. cuneata have firmly united spores that only separate after considerable pressure, which differentiate them from Th. anthemidis that has loose spore balls. Further, Th. arnicae (spore balls comprised of up to 25 spores), Th. californica (6–20 spores) and Th. solidaginis (8 to 50 or more spores) have larger spore balls with larger numbers of spores than Th. anthemidis. The spores of Th. cuneata are radially arranged within the spore balls and Th. burkartii has spores with an outer wall 5–9 µm thick, which is more than three times thicker than in Th. anthemidis. Thecaphora lagenophorae and Th. trailii are morphologically most similar to Th. anthemidis. Thecaphora lagenophorae is only known to infect Solenogyne gunnii (tribe Astereae) in Australia (
The present study is the first to identify a species of Thecaphora on a host plant species in the tribe Anthemideae (Asteraceae) (see
Previously, only two ITS sequences of Thecaphora species infecting Asteraceae (Th. spilanthis and Th. hennenea) were available on GenBank, which together with the new sequences reported in this study, represents only 20% of all Thecaphora species known to occur on Asteraceae. In addition to the sequence of Th. anthemidis, we have provided barcode sequences of the ITS region for eight other taxa not previously available on GenBank (Table I). Future studies should address whether species of Thecaphora that infect the flower heads of Asteraceae form a monophyletic group.
The authors are grateful to Ulrike Damm and Michaela Schwager of the Herbarium Senckenbergianum Görlitz (