Descriptions of five new species in Entoloma subgenus Claudopus from China, with molecular phylogeny of Entoloma s.l.

Abstract Entoloma subgenus Claudopus is widely distributed, yet the taxonomy and systematics of its species are still poorly documented. In the present study, more than forty collections of Claudopus were gathered in China and subsequently analysed, based on morphological and molecular data. The results revealed first a high level of species diversity of Claudopus in China and second, there is a wide ecological range regarding the substrates and the habitats ranging from temperate, tropical to subalpine locations. Based on morphological and molecular evidence, five novel species from China are proposed, viz. E. conchatum, E. flabellatum, E. gregarium, E. pleurotoides and E. reductum. Molecular phylogeny of Entoloma s.l. was also reconstructed, based on 187 representatives of Entoloma s.l. by employing the combined ITS, LSU, mtSSU and RPB2 sequences. Ten monophyletic clades (Claudopus, Leptonia, Nolanea, Cuboid-spored Inocephalus, “Alboleptonia”, Cyanula, Pouzarella, Rhodopolia, Prunuloides and Rusticoides) were recovered, while 13 taxa could not be placed in any defined clades. The results confirmed that Claudopus in a traditional morphological sense is not monophyletic and the Rusticoides-group, previously considered within Claudopus, formed a separate clade; but section Claudopus and relatives of E. undatum belong to a distinctive monophyletic group. Despite some monophyletic groups in Entoloma s.l. being distinctive in both morphology and molecular phylogeny, they were still treated as subgenera of Entoloma s.l. temporarily, because accepting them as genera will make Entoloma s.l. paraphyletic.


Introduction
Entoloma P. Kumm. is a large agaric genus and more than 1000 species have been reported worldwide. Subgenus Claudopus is one of the most distinctive groups in this genus. By comparison, the pleurotoid or omphalinoid basidiomes of all described species of Claudopus are small and, accordingly, are often overlooked and thus neglected during field work. Macromorphologically, members of Claudopus are characterised by the fibrillose, non-gelatinised pileipellis and the eccentric, lateral or absent stipe. Macroscopically, fresh basidiomes of Claudopus are readily confused with species belonging to genera Clitopilus (Fr. ex Rabenh.) P. Kumm., Crepidotus (Fr.) Staude, Hohenbuehelia Schulzer, Marasmiellus Murrill or Pleurotellus Fayod but, under the microscope, the identification of Claudopus is immediately confirmed by the typical angular basidiospores.
To date, the taxonomic position of Claudopus (and of other entolomatoid taxa) is still controversial and unresolved. Horak (1980Horak ( , 2008 accommodated pleurotoid Claudopus at generic level. Largent (1994) proposed 13 entolomatoid genera, including Claudopus as a recognised genus. Noordeloos (1992Noordeloos ( , 2004 proposed that Claudopus should be included in the genus Entoloma. All these proposals were based on morphological characters. However, molecular analysis has substantially altered traditional concepts in many fungal groups, showing that the taxonomic delimitation, based on morphological characters alone, is in fact artificial and speculative (Li et al. 2011;Chen et al. 2016;Han et al. 2016). In recent years, molecular markers have also been employed in phylogenetic studies on entolomatoid groups. In a paper by Co-David et al. (2009), three Claudopus species are nested in the monophyletic Nolanea-Claudopus Clade. As a consequence, the authors concluded that the traditional concept of Claudopus is polyphyletic. However, it was obvious that the number of samples was too limited to support the placement of Claudopus within Nolanea. Two subsequent molecular phylogenetic studies have also demonstrated that Claudopus (only pleurotoid species and relatives of E. undatum (Gillet) M.M. Moser were included) was grouped with Nolanea and Leptonia members, but no significant support was received (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Kinoshita et al. 2012). However, it is noteworthy that, in these studies, Claudopus species were actually nested in a monophyletic subclade (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Kinoshita et al. 2012). In two more recent studies He et al. 2015), the results suggested that section Claudopus and E. undatum complex species could belong to a monophyletic group. Additionally, E. rusticoides (Gillet) Noordel. and associated taxa in sect. Undatum (Noordeloos 2004) are rather distant from the monophyletic Claudopus lineage . However, in all the previous studies, limited taxa of Claudopus were included to support these conclusions and we expect that the topologies of the phylogenetic trees will probably significantly change with the increase in samples taken into account.
There are several reasons why the taxonomy of Claudopus worldwide is not well understood yet. For many species, the original descriptive documentation is inadequate and/or type material is either not extant or in poor condition (Horak, unpubl. data). In addition, the knowledge of macroscopic and microscopic characters of nearly all described species is limited, at least by comparison with taxa of Entoloma s.l. The colour of the young basidiomes ranges from white, grey to pale brown. Bluish colours are the exception and are observed only in a few species (Horak 1980;Manimohan et al. 2002;Morozova et al. 2012). As a rule, the majority of the original descriptions are relying on macromorphological features which have led to persisting confusion regarding the circumscription of taxa. Furthermore, the number of reliable microscopical characters (basidiospores, pileipellis structure) is restricted. Distinctive cheilocystidia are not found in most species of Claudopus. Presence or absence of clamp connections (in particular at the basal septum of basidia) have not been given adequate attention in many of the earlier descriptions. Only recently, few species of Claudopus have been described by combining both morphologic and molecular data Vila et al. 2014;Deng et al. 2015;He et al. 2015). Accordingly, identification of Claudopus, based on both morphological characters and molecular markers, will be helpful to fill a gap in our knowledge of Claudopus and bring clarifications regarding taxonomic relationships in this group.
To better understand the phylogeny of the genus Entoloma s.l. and the placement of Claudopus in this genus, a more comprehensive molecular phylogeny of Entoloma s.l. was carried out by employing the combined ITS, LSU, mtSSU and RPB2 sequences in the present paper. On the other hand, both descriptive and molecular information about 5 new taxa in subgenus Claudopus recently discovered at various localities in China is provided and the first record of Entoloma byssisedum var.  (Deng et al. 2015;He et al. 2015). It can be assumed that the number of Chinese representatives of Claudopus will significantly increase with further fieldwork.

Morphological descriptions
Photographs of fresh specimens are taken in situ and all relevant ecological data are recorded at the actual habitat. All macromorphologic descriptions are also based on fresh material. Colour notations follow Kornerup and Wanscher (1978). Micromorphologic data are sketched with the help of a drawing tube attached to a Wild M 20 microscope. Basidiospores, basidia and pileipellis were mounted and measured in 5% potassium hydroxide (KOH) and/or 1% Congo Red. Measurements of the basidiospores exclude hilar appendix (apiculus). Q is used to mean "length/width ratio" of a basidiospore in profile view; ± means sample standard deviation; Q means average Q of all basidiospores; x means of basidiospore length and width. All holotype collections are kept in the Mycological Herbarium of Soil and Fertilizer Institute, Sichuan Academy of Agricultural Sciences (SAAS); isotypes and duplicates are preserved in Herbarium ZT, ETH, Zurich, Switzerland.

Sequence alignment and phylogenetic analyses
Phylogenetic analyses were carried out, based on the ITS dataset and the combined dataset of ITS, nLSU, RPB2 and mtSSU. Sequences used in analysis are listed in table 1 and aligned in muscle 3.6 (Edgar 2004). If necessary, the aligned sequences were manually modified employing BioEdit 7.0.9.0 (Hall 1999). Representative sequences, published in previous studies, focused on entolomatoid fungi and new sequences, generated in this study, were selected for the present molecular analyses (Co-David et al. 2009;Baroni and Matheny 2011;Largent et al. 2011;Kinoshita et al. 2012;Morgado et al. 2013;Morozova et al. 2014;Vila et al. 2014;He et al. 2015;Kokkonen 2015). The quality of these sequences was further accessed and those sequences in low quality were excluded in the present study. Almost all representative species in these studies were included. No conflicts between the ITS, nLSU, RPB2 and mtSSU datasets were observed by comparing the topologies resulting from the phylogenetic analysis of the single gene and therefore they were combined in the analysis.
Maximum Likehood (ML), Maximum Parsimony (MP) and Bayesian analyses were performed on the combined dataset, respectively. ML analyses were carried out by the web RAxML Version 8 (http://www.phylo.org/sub_sections/portal/) under the GTR+G+T model with 1000 bootstrap replicates (Stamatakis 2014). "Find best tree using maximum likelihood search" option was selected when analysing. MP analyses was performed using PAUP* version 4.0b10 (Swofford 2003). All characters were treated as unordered and of equal weight. Gaps were treated as missing data. Bootstrap values (BS) were calculated from 1000 replicates. Bayesian analyses were performed using MrBayes 3.2.6 (Ronquist and Huelsenbeck 2003). The best substitution models for each marker were selected by using Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) in jModelTest 2.1.7 (Darriba et al. 2012). GTR+I+G model was employed for nLSU, mtSSU and ITS, SYM+G for RPB2. Six Markov chains were run for 2 runs from random starting trees for 15 million generations and sampled every 100 generations. Average standard deviation of split frequencies below 0.05 is an indication of convergence. Bayesian Posterior Probabilities (BPP) were determined after calculating a 75% majority rule consensus tree. Sequences ex holotype. KU312111 (ITS), KU534220 (nLSU), KU534459 (RPB2), KU534432 (mtSSU).

Entoloma conchatum
Etymology. conchatum (Lat.), referring to the conchate shape of the basidiomes. Diagnosis. Entoloma conchatum closely resembles Entoloma parasiticum (Quél.) Kreisel, described from Europe and N-America but differs by smaller basidiospores. The Australian C. viscosus is separated from E. conchatum by its sticky pileus and the absence of rhizoids at the base of the rudimentary stipe.
Remarks. Entoloma flabellatum is distinguished by the small and pleurotoid basidiomes, prominent white rhizoids attached to the rudimentary lateral stipe and (5-) 6-angled basidiospores measuring 7.5-8.5 × 5.5-6.5 μm. The basidiomes are white at first but gradually change to yellowish or orange with age. Numerous species of Claudopus recorded from SE-Asia and Australasia are characterised by white basidiomes, cf. Horak (1980), Manimohan et al. (2002), Noordeloos (2004), Largent et al. (2011) and Noordeloos and Gates (2012). The Chinese E. flabellatum closely resembles the following three taxa recently described from Australia viz. E. pitereka which differs by larger basidiospores (8-12 × 6-8 μm, Noordeloos and Gates 2012), spermatic odour and nutty taste. In addition, the ecology of E. flabellatum and E. pitereka differs distinctly: E. pitereka is reported to occur on rotten wood-bark in wet Eucalyptus forest, while E. flabellatum is found on rotten wood-bark in subtropical bamboo forest of SW-China. C. minutoincanus is also similar to the Chinese E. flabellatum, but is distinguished by more isodiameteric basidiospores (7.4-11.4 × 6.3-9.6 μm, Q = 1.08-1.44, Largent et al. 2011). In addition, the RPB2 sequence of E. flabellatum is 97% identical to that of C. minutoincanus, indicating that they are closely related, but separate species. Macroscopically and microscopically C. viscosus is difficult to separate from E. flabellatum. However, apart from different size of the basidiospores, the RPB2 sequences of the two species have no significant molecular similarity and thus indicate to represent different and not closely related species (Fig. 9). Etymology. gregarium (Lat.), referring to gregarious habit. Diagnosis. Entoloma gregarium resembles the Chinese E. conchatum, but differs by smaller basidiospores.
Based on macromorphological characters, E. gregarium is difficult to distinguish from E. crepidotoides (Deng et al. 2015); however, the different habitats allow the two species to be discriminated. Additionally, the molecular evidence (Figs 8, 9) of E. crepidotoides and E. gregarium clearly indicate that they are two distinctive species. E. indocarneum is characterised by smooth pileus and presence of mycelial rhizoids (Manimohan et al. 2002). Claudopus pandanicola, originally described from tropical Papua New Guinea, is separated by the striate pileus and the different shape of the basidiospores (7-8 × 6.5-7.5 μm, Horak 1980 Etymology. pleurotoides (Lat.), referring to the pleurotoid shape of the basidiomes. Diagnosis. Entoloma pleurotoides is close to the Australian E. pitereka, but differs by smaller and more isodiameteric basidiospores.
Habitat. Amongst moss at base of living Castanopsis sp. or on decaying debris of Remarks. Entoloma pleurotoides is characterised by white, small and pleurotoid basidiomes, presence of basal rhizoids and isodiametric to subisodiametric basidiospores.
Macromorphologically, E. pleurotoides closely resembles E. pitereka which, however, differs by more heterodiametric basidiospores (Noordeloos and Gates 2012). Two other Australian species of Claudopus (C. rupestris, C. viscosus) possess basal rhizoids but, contrary to E. pleurotoides, are recognised by 4-5-angled, heterodiametric basidi-ospores . Basal rhizoids are also reported for the Indian E. indocarneum (Manimohan et al. 2006), which is separated by smooth pileus and more pronounced heterodiametric basidiospores (7.5-10 × 5-7 μm, Manimohan et al. 2002). Concerning macromorphologic characters, E. pleurotoides is difficult to separate from the following E. flabellatum discovered in China; however, the latter differs by the more distinctive heterodiametric basidiospores. In addition, molecular evidence further confirms that the two taxa represent two defined species. The ITS sequences of E. flabellatum are 88% identical to those of E. pleurotoides. Etymology. reductum (Lat.), referring to the reduced stipe. Diagnosis. Entoloma reductum is similar to E. byssisedum but differs by the size of the basidiospores.
Habitat. On decaying stump of Betula sp. in deciduous forest dominated by Betula sp. and Quercus sp. Remarks. Entoloma byssisedum var. microsporum closely resembles typical E. byssisedum by its small crepidotoid pale greyish-brown basidiomes whose pileipellis is covered with fine, whitish arachnoid fibrils and lateral, strongly reduced to absent stipe. However, the basidiospores of the Chinese specimens are distinctly smaller as recorded for typical E. byssisedum and, thus, the morphotaxonomic characters correspond well with European collections of E. byssisedum var. microsporum (Noordeloos 2004). The identification is further supported by ITS sequences which demonstrate that the Chinese specimens of E. byssisedum var. microsporum are 99% identical as compared to those reported for European material (KJ001409). It is noteworthy that, in GenBank, there are two sequences labelled "E. byssisedum" (EU784209, KJ001413) which, however, are significantly different. The ITS sequences of the Chinese E. byssisedum var. microsporum are 97% identical to EU784209 but do not correspond with KJ001413. Accordingly, it could be speculated that E. byssisedum var. microsporum and E. byssisedum var. byssisedum actually represent two different species.

Molecular analyses
The new sequences presented in this study are deposited in GenBank with accession numbers KU312103-KU312125, KU534215-KU534217, KU534219-KU534238, KU534415-KU534436 and KU534459-KU534482. In the phylogenetic analysis, the final ITS dataset included 43 sequences; E. omiense, E. stylophorum and E. subtenuicystidiatum were designed as outgroups. The ITS dataset contained 702 nucleotide sites, of which 416 characters were constant, 175 were parsimony-informative characters and 111 variable characters were parsimony-uninformative. Two most parsimonious trees were recovered, based on ITS sequences and one of them is shown (Fig. 8).

Discussion
Five new species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus from China were described based on morphological and molecular data. Additionally, the phylogeny of Entoloma was also carried out, based on the combined ITS, LSU, mtSSU and RPB2 sequences. Co-David et al. (2009) presented a relatively comprehensive molecular phylogeny on Entolomataceae (54 representatives of Entoloma were included). Since then, several molecular studies focusing on entolomatoid agarics have been reported (Baroni and Matheny 2011;He et al. 2013;Kinoshita et al. 2012;Kokkonen 2015;Morgado et al. 2013;Morozova et al. 2014;Vila et al. 2014). Most of these studies were focused on one certain group or subgenus in Entoloma s.l. and samples used in phylogenetic analyses were mainly limited to the studied groups (He et al. 2013;Kokkonen 2015;Morgado et al. 2013;Morozova et al. 2014;Vila et al. 2014). This study provides a more comprehensive phylogeny, based on the sequences newly generated and includes almost all the representatives published in those previous studies (187 representatives of Entoloma were included). This is also the first contribution providing a relatively densely sampled systematic treatment of Claudopus. It is noteworthy that Claudopus in a traditional morphological sense is not monophyletic and the Rusticoides-group, previously considered within Claudopus, formed a separate clade; but the pleurotoid or crepidotoid Claudopus members, as well as E. abortivum (Berk. & Curt.) Donk, E. undatum and its related taxa, are placed in a distinctive monophyletic clade.

Phylogenetic analyses of combined datasets
In combined phylogenies, Entoloma s.l. is divided into ten monophyletic groups (Fig. 9). The majority of these groups are well defined regarding macro or micromorphology. The most distinctive group is the Pouzarella, whose taxonomic position as a monophyletic group is also supported by both morphologic and molecular evidence (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Co-David et al. 2009;He et al. 2013). In the previous studies, Claudopus species were nested in the nolanea-claudopus clade, based on very limited samples (Baroni and Matheny 2010;Co-David et al. 2009). However, on the basis of a more comprehensive sampling in the present study, it is obvious that Claudopus (E. rusticoides and relatives are excluded) is a monophyletic group clearly separated from Nolanea. Claudopus and Nolanea species are grouped as monophyletic groups, respectively, in different clades. In the present analysis, clade Rusticoides (traditionally considered within Claudopus) is also recognised to be monophyletic and is separated from Claudopus. Research data have indicated that traditional Leptonia (either as genus or subgenus) might be polyphyletic and species accommodated in section Cyanula are distantly related to section Leptonia (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Co-David et al. 2009). In Noordeloos and Gates (2012), section Cyanula was raised to subgeneric level and the concept of subgenus Leptonia was also emended. The present analysis further proved that the traditional concept of subgenus Leptonia is polyphyletic. In the previous studies, section Leptonia belonged to the /nolanea-claudopus clade, section Cyanula to the / inocephalus-cyanula clade, respectively. However, monophyly of section Leptonia and Cyanula are clearly demonstrated in this study. Section Leptonia is clearly separated from Nolanea and Claudopus and Cyanula is distinguished from Inocephalus (cuboid-spored Inocephalus), respectively. Two taxa in the traditional "Alboleptonia" (A. stylophora and A. aff. sericella) are grouped in the monophyletic clade Cyanula, while the following  Kumm.) are placed in a separated clade. These results suggest that "Alboleptonia" in the traditional circumscription might not be a well-defined genus or subgenus and the concept of Cyanula also needs to be revised. Polyphyly of the traditional Inocephalus is further confirmed in the present analyses. However, all analysed cuboid-spored species belonging to Inocephalus are clustered in a monophyletic clade, suggesting that these species may represent a distinct monophyletic group. The clade Rhodopolia (Clade 9) received strong support in the ML and Bayesian analysis which, however, is not supported by MP analysis. In the strongly supported Prunuloides clade, members in the emended subgenus Entoloma (Noordeloos and Gates 2012) were included and it is distant from the subgenus Rhodopolia, which is consistent with the previous studies (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Co-David et al. 2009). One internal clade includes 5 species of the traditional Prunuloides and 4 species [E. haastii G. Stev., E. nitidum Quél., E. trachyosporum Largent and E. turbidum (Fr.) Quél.] that belong to the genus Entocybe established by ; however, it seems that it will cause subgenus Prunuloides to be paraphyletic if these entocyboid species are excluded from subgenus Prunuloides for the time being. The results also showed that sequestrate form (E. prismaticum, E. hypogaeum, E. asterosporum and Entoloma sp.) in Entoloma have multiple origins, which is consistent with the previous studies (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Kinoshita et al. 2012).
In conclusion: It can be safely predicted that, within entolomatoid agarics, further monophyletic lineages will be discovered as soon as the number of molecular information increases and, subsequently, the present classification of Entoloma s.l. is going to change fundamentally.

Phylogenetic species determination of Claudopus
The variation of macroscopic characters in many species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus is limited and, accordingly, it is difficult or even impossible to identify morphologically similar taxa. In the future, it will be essential to recognise and describe new species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus in combination with molecular data and morphological characters. Molecular analyses convincingly show that, regarding species of Claudopus, both ITS and RPB2 sequences have a high discriminating potential to separate species. In the present phylogenetic data, thirty-five sequences representing twenty-one phylogenetic species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus are uncovered. It is herewith emphasised that nine species have now been recorded and four unidentified species have been collected from China which suggests that species diversity of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus is high in this country.
In the present ITS analysis (Fig. 8), two sequences labelled "Entoloma byssisedum" (EU784209, KJ001413) and one sequence referred to as E. byssisedum var. microsporum (KJ001409) are included. The relevant voucher material was collected in Europe. However, the molecular tree(s) demonstrates that the three sequences are nested in different clades: KJ001413 is distant from EU784209 and KJ001413. Consequently, it can be speculated that the European E. byssisedum var. microsporum could be a distinctive species rather than a variety. Furthermore, the sequenced European materials, identified as E. byssisedum, is composed of a complex of as yet unnamed species or even more likely to misidentification of species of similar basidiomes. A similar situation is observed regarding E. undatum. In GenBank, sequences retrieved from several collections of E. undatum (ITS: KJ001412, JF908007; LSU: AF207199, GQ289202, KJ001455) are obviously different and belong to different species taxonomically not disentangled yet.

Ecology of Chinese taxa of Claudopus
Fieldwork demonstrated that the Chinese species of Claudopus are found in different habitats, characterised by distinctive ecology and substrates, (e.g. bark-wood of decaying debris of fallen or live broadleaf trees and conifers, soil in grassland or mosscovered rock). Unlike other entolomatoid species, the habitat on above-ground decaying wooden substrates is the rule for members of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus, while occurrence on bark-wood of live trees was not mentioned before in the relevant literature. The present results indicate, however, that growth on bark-wood of live trees is not uncommon for Chinese species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus.
Based on present records, it is remarkable that, in China, the distribution of Claudopus stretches from tropical lowland forests (E. crepidotoides, from Hainan Prov.) to temperate and finally also to alpine localities in Sichuan Prov. (E. alpinum) or Xizang Autonomous Region, Tibet (E. byssisedum var. microsporum).
It must be emphasised that ecological data alone do not help to identify the Chinese taxa reported in the present contribution. As an example: based on available reports, E. reductum was found in different habitats and localities. The records from Sichuan Prov. were discovered on soil and moss-covered rock, but the specimens gathered in Yunnan Prov. are lignicolous. Despite different habitats, the microscopic examination and molecular data confirmed that the aforementioned records of E. reductum are identical. A similar observation was made regarding E. conchatum and E. pleurotoides. To confirm the identification of Claudopus, based on references relating to substrate/habitat, are not reliable unless morphotaxonomic characters and molecular data are also taken into consideration.

Diagnostic characters of Claudopus and the taxonomic position of Entoloma abortivum
In the large majority of entolomatoid species, the stipe is central and well developed. However, in some taxa of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus, the stipe is absent or strongly reduced and some species possess well-developed but eccentrically inserted stipes. In the tested Claudopus species, viz. E. abortivum, E. alpinum, E. undatum, E. sericeonitidum (P.D. Orton) Arnolds and an unidentified taxon (SAAS 1154), the stipes are well developed; while in other taxa strongly reduced and laterally attached stipes are observed. All of the above enumerated species are nested in the Claudopus clade with a strong support. In the study of Vila et al. (2014), E. korhonenii Noordel., as well as several other Claudopus species, form a monophyletic group based on ITS sequences. The only common macro-character derived from the descriptions of these members, except for E. undatum, E. korhonenii and E. sericeonitidum, is that the stipes are off-centre which might be a key character for the recognition of Claudopus. It should be emphasised that the eccentric stipe should be a stabile and reliable character rather than an accidental adaptation to substrate in the habitats. During our field survey, we always found that the stipes of E. abortivum, E. alpinum and SAAS 1154 are off-centre or even eccentric.
Apparently, the stipe is also eccentrically inserted -but not properly mentioned in the relevant descriptions -in basidiomes of E. undatum, E. sericeonitidum and E. korhoneni. The eccentric position of the stipe can be observed in photographs of E. undatum and E. korhonenii (Noordeloos 2004). The picture of E. sericeonitidum (Paraeccilia sericeonitida) in Largent (1994) also showed that the stipe is slightly off-centre. In the future, the character "position of stipe" should be taken more carefully into consideration to support the hypothesis that this diagnostic feature is characteristic for the delimitation of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus.
Based on published records and collections from China, basidiomes of E. abortivum occur in two morphs viz. first with typical agaricoid and second with secotioid basidiomes. Regardless ofthe insertion of the stipe, the taxonomic position of E. abortivum was uncertain until molecular methods revealed that this taxon actually represents a typical species of Entoloma subgenus Claudopus (Baroni and Matheny 2011;Co-David et al. 2009;He et al. 2013;Vila et al. 2014). In the current descriptions of E. abortivum, the attachment of the stipe is not mentioned in particular. However, in our Chinese material, the position of the stipe of E. abortivum is always slightly but distinctly off-centre.